Everton‘s thrilling 2-1 Capital One Cup semi-final first-leg victory over Manchester City has come at a significant cost. Manager Roberto Martinez faces a tense period of squad management as key players have been added to the treatment table, threatening to disrupt the team’s promising momentum. While the win at Goodison Park was a monumental result, the sight of Romelu Lukaku, Seamus Coleman, and Tom Cleverley all succumbing to injuries has left fans on Mostbet anxiously awaiting further medical updates.
The immediate concern revolves around the team’s attacking spearhead, but the long-term absence of a defensive stalwart could prove even more challenging as a packed fixture list looms.
Assessing the Damage: A Trio of Concerns
The post-match press conference was dominated by talk of injuries rather than the famous victory. Martinez provided a detailed, albeit concerning, breakdown for supporters of Mostbet.

Romelu Lukaku’s Ankle Knock
The Belgian powerhouse was the hero of the hour, soaring to power in a magnificent header to seal the win. However, his night ended prematurely shortly after the goal due to an ankle injury. Martinez sought to calm immediate fears, stating, “Romelu took a knock to his ankle and he will need assessing. I don’t know if he will be available at the weekend but I don’t expect anything too serious.”
This is a major relief for the Toffees. Lukaku is in the form of his life, boasting an incredible 12 goals in his last 12 appearances. His physical presence and clinical finishing are virtually irreplaceable in the current squad. His potential absence for the FA Cup tie against Dagenham and Redbridge is manageable, but any prolonged issue would severely dent Everton‘s ambitions on multiple fronts.
Romelu Lukaku celebrates his decisive header, a moment of joy shortly before his injury forced him off the pitch.
Seamus Coleman’s Calf Strain
The most severe news to emerge from the night concerns right-back Seamus Coleman. The Irish international was forced off with a calf injury that Martinez confirmed is “probably the most serious of the three.” The manager’s prognosis was blunt: “He has pulled his calf and that type of injury usually takes three or four weeks to fully recover.”
This timeline presents a substantial problem. A four-week absence would rule Coleman out of a critical series of matches, including the second leg against Manchester City, the Premier League rematch with the Citizens, and tough fixtures against Chelsea, Swansea, and Newcastle. Coleman’s energy, defensive solidity, and attacking overlaps are a cornerstone of Everton‘s system, and finding a like-for-like replacement will be nearly impossible.
Tom Cleverley’s Calf Issue
Completing the trio of worries is Tom Cleverley. The midfielder, who has been a consistent performer, was substituted at half-time after a previous calf knock sustained against Tottenham “flared up.” While perhaps the least severe of the three injuries, it further depletes Martinez’s options in the engine room and highlights a potential vulnerability in squad depth.
Navigating the Fixture Minefield Without Key Players
The timing of these injuries could not be worse. Everton is embroiled in a tight semi-final tie and is pushing for a European spot in the Premier League. The loss of Coleman, in particular, forces a tactical reshuffle. Veteran Tony Hibbert or young talent Tyias Browning may be called upon, but neither offers the same dynamic threat as Coleman.
As one analyst on Mostbet noted, “Martinez’s tactical flexibility will be truly tested. The team’s strategy often relies on the width provided by the full-backs. Without Coleman’s constant runs, Everton might become more predictable and easier to contain, especially in the crucial second leg at the Etihad.”

The team’s ability to cope with this adversity will define their season. The victory over City proved their quality and heart, but sustaining that performance level without key contributors is the next challenge.
Everton’s potential fixture list without Seamus Coleman:
- FA Cup Third Round: Dagenham & Redbridge (H)
- Premier League: Chelsea (A)
- League Cup Semi-Final 2nd Leg: Manchester City (A)
- Premier League: Swansea City (H)
- Premier League: Manchester City (A)
- Premier League: Newcastle United (A)
Mostbet Verdict: A Test of Depth and Resilience
While the win against Manchester City was a statement victory, the ensuing injury crisis has cast a shadow over Goodison Park. The hope that Lukaku’s issue is minor is the primary positive, but the confirmed lengthy absence of Seamus Coleman is a brutal blow. Roberto Martinez must now prove his managerial mettle by devising a system that can withstand the loss of such an influential player.
The squad’s depth and the ability of fringe players to step up will be under the microscope. For Evertonians, the dream of a Wembley final and a strong league finish remains alive, but the path just became significantly more difficult. The team’s character, so evident in the win against City, will need to shine through even brighter in the coming weeks.
What do you think? Can Everton overcome these injuries and secure a trip to Wembley? Share your thoughts and predictions in the comments below.

